Tagul, Wordle and myself
Recently Jonathan Feinberg, the creator of Wordle wrote a blog post about Tagul. If you don’t know Wordle is a toy for generating “word clouds” that are very similar to Tagul. In this post I am going to explain the difference between Tagul and Wordle and expose the motives that led to Tagul creation.
At first, I don’t like being mentioned as a person “who identifies himself only as Alex”. I admit there is a lack of info about me so far and therefore I am going to spot some light on my bio.
Bio
I was born in 1982 in Moscow, Russia. So I am 27 years old at the moment of writing this post and still located there. I am keen on computers since childhood. My first programming experience was altering BASIC code on an Atari computer to get more lives in an action game
. I was 10 years old then. Later on I got Master’s degree on computer science from Moscow State University. Despite my loving programming I have never worked as a programmer. My latest position is a business analyst in a bank. I am married and have a wonderful 2 years old son.
A story behind Tagul
Having that said, I felt unsatisfied in my professional life being an employee of a bank. It was quite far from technology and real challenge. So I desided to try myself as an entrepreneur in the internet area, as it was the easiest way for a person with programming skills. I spent some time looking for a great idea to implement and once I noticed that there were a lot of tag clouds in the internet, but virtually all of them were ugly and didn’t look like clouds at all. So I decided to make a web service that would enable users to create true tag clouds. Here is an example of my early work: 
Then I found Wordle and was amazed by its capability of placing text inside text. I was inspired by this idea so much, so I decided to implement it in Tagul. It was a tough task but I did it. It takes me a year of hard work in my spare time (free from full time job) to implement the idea from scratch to early beta stage where Tagul is now. Here is an example of a modern Tagul cloud:
Tagul is different
Wordle was designed to be just a toy. Wordle clouds cannot be used as in the way tag clouds are usually used, like being embedded on a web page and serving as navigation units. That leaves the niche that Tagul is intended to fulfil. Tagul clouds are not toys and designed to be used on blogs, web pages or any kind of sites as a replacement of ordinary tag clouds. Each tag in Tagul cloud is linked with an URL and is “clickable” that enables visitors to use it for navigation. Also Tagul utilizes widely used flash platform (instead of less common java platform in Wordle) that is light weight (~50kb per cloud vs ~150kb) and stores the clouds on a CDN to deliver clouds to wide audience instanlty. Tagul has some features that Wordle doesn’t, like custom shapes selection and multiply fonts usage in one cloud. Finally, Tagul is a startup and I am going to make a profit on this venture some day.
Alex, Did you ever think of doing anything educational with tagul? I love wordle, but it’s not really educationally appropriate because people can post whatever they want. My school loves to use them and as a teacher, I would like to see if my kids could accounts as well.
You know, I didn’t. Educational use is not a priority for Tagul, but I’d love to know that Tagul is used for teaching kids. I don’t know educational needs well and don’t know how to make Tagul educational friendly, so I would appreciate if you specify what needs to be done and I will see what I can do.
As an educator – I would love to use Tagul with vocabulary lessons to capture my students’ immediate interest! I am just a newbie here, so lots to learn…I am having fun doing so!
please consider allowing a free educator account version o this software.
here are just a few links that i pulled together quickly but there are many more and lots of educators at all levels using the tool.
http://www.educationworld.com/a_tech/columnists/dyck/dyck030.shtml
http://www.techedknow.com/?p=56
http://blog.ecollege.com/WordPress/?p=115
http://mpondu.blogspot.com/2009/12/educational-uses-of-wordle.html
http://livebinders.com/play/play_or_edit/3017
Alex, this tool is powerful for education. Students can produce quick and meaningful presentations and study aids that are current and cool. They also work very well on “interactive whiteboards.” Many great web tools are free for K-12 education, so thank you for providing such a creative alternative for students and teachers.
I love the idea of Wordle and Tagul because it gives weighting for the importance of words. I would really like to create a word cloud where the words are clickable and then go to a place where there is a definition of the word, a bit like a Wiki! Can Tagul do this?
Sure it can be done with Tagul. You should use API mode to obtain the full control of your cloud.
Alex, this site is a blessing! I am in the heart of North Philadelphia with 10 year old Dell computers. My kids love this site! They are graffiti crazy! We will use the site as a reflection tool too summarize what the kids have learned in class. Where do we post the clouds?
Patrick
It is supposed that you post clouds on a web page. But as I can see from your description it is not your case. You can just grab a screen shot and save it as an image for your purposes. You can also check out http://wordle.net, it is cool as well.
I get it. Tagul is not a replacement for Wordle, but has a different purpose.
I like to compare articles about the same event from different newspapers to look for points of view and biases with Wordle.
Tagul would really be useful for projects I do with students both in K-12 and at the college level.
I’ll let you know what comes up as I begin to use Tagul.
Hi Alex,
thanks a lot for your great work. Hav you considered to release this as free software? You can still make money and additionally, make this world a bit better. Imagine how community can improve your work … and you’ll get a great success and impact on internet media. Well, I’m just an user, and I would like yo see your code working on lots of places. Unfortunately, I will not pay when Tagul (sounds like Nazgul, the black monster-birds at The Lord of the Rings …) finally go propietary …I’m just an user, and not very wealthy X-)
anyway, thanks a lot and great work!
miguel
all i can say is WOW!!!
As an educator I can see many uses for Tagul. Having been in business many years I also see the need to make a profit. I think with Tagul there is room for both…possibly with advertising as a source of revenue. I think the number of hits Tagul is going to receive is going to sky rocket soon.